Rhys could always return in Joe's hallucinations.
Nonetheless, pretty much anything is possible in the world of You. It seems unlikely that any of them will return in season 5. With Malcolm (Stephen Hagan), Simon (Aidan Cheng), Gemma (Eve Austin), Adam (Lukas Gage) and Rhys (Ed Speelers) all dead now. Here are the suriving You season 4 characters that could appear in season 5. Occasionally characters stick around for more but that all depends on whether or not they survive. WARNING: YOU SEASON 4 PART 2 SPOILERS BELOWĪs you already know, the You cast tends to change a lot from season to season with the only constant being Penn Badgley as Joe Goldberg.
It's currently unclear if You season 5 will be split into two parts like season 4 or not. The WGA (Writers Guild of America) have also been on strike since May 2023 for similar reasons.
